I can tell you exactly when the pain started. I was riding my bike in Forest Park, the great urban park of St. Louis. Ordinarily, I cycle from my house to the park, cutting across the ivy-covered semi-Ivy league campus of nearby Washington University and circling its beautiful acres on a recently refinished bike path.
As I started the slow incline that parallels Skinker Avenue just West of Forest Park, a cyclist flashed past me. I could swear he said “Oh dear, oh dear. I shall be late.”
Instead of continuing straight along the bike path, the late cyclist suddenly veered to the left, following a heretofore untraveled spur that led up into the dark, impenetrable forests of the park.
At this point, the sensible, sixty-something portion of my psyche should have taken over and had me continue on the relatively straight, flat and well-traveled road that I had grown accustomed to. Alas, it was the teenage boy who took control and insisted on us taking the road less traveled.
The spur of the bike path had not been regularly maintained and there were numerous rough spots: ridges and chasms emerged with disconcerting frequency as I progressed.
The lure of exploration pulled me on. I kept my speed up as I descended a hill with the path turning sharply to the right. Suddenly an even sharper right turn emerged with a particularly uneven section of path. I lost control of the bike and landed heavily on my left side.
I felt a sudden sharp pain just to the left of my breastbone about midway in my chest.
As a cardiologist I spend a lot of time talking to people about chest pain and thinking about what is causing it.
The heart is in the chest and it is natural to believe that pain that comes from this area could be a manifestation of the dreaded heart attack. Since heart attacks are the #1 killer of both men and women and they can very quickly lead to life-threatening arrhythmias it is wise to take seriously any pain in the chest.
Three Types of Chest Pain
I was trained to sort what patient’s described to me about their chest pain into three bins: Typical anginal pain, atypical anginal pain and non cardiac pain.
Angina is doctor-speak for chest pain that is due to the heart muscle not getting enough blood (usually due to a blocked coronary artery)
Cardiologists consider any discomfort from the lower ribs up to the bottom of the neck as chest pain although patients often don’t perceive it as a pain.
Heart attack pain often feels like a pressure, a heaviness or a burning and in addition to somewhere in the anterior chest region it can manifest in the neck or jaw or one or both of the upper arms.
My chest pain was worse when I took a deep breath (pleuritic) and this almost always indicates a lung cause or inflammation in the muscle/bones/joints that are related to breathing. Furthermore, pushing on the ribs made it worse making it virtually certain that it was musculoskeletal.
A brief (well done) history and physical exam therefore would assign my chest pain to the “non cardiac” bin.
Typical anginal pain is brought on by exertion, lasts 3-15 minutes and is relieved by nitroglycerin or rest.
The probability of a patient with non cardiac chest pain having significantly blocked coronary arteries is generally lower than that of a patient with typical anginal pain. However, as this chart demonstrates, patients (generally those with significant risk factors) can have severely blocked coronary arteries and have non cardiac chest pain.
For example, I have risk factors of age (>55 years), being male, hyperlipidemia and hypertension. A cardiac catheterization done on me at the time of my non cardiac chest pain might well show significantly blocked coronary arteries. Of course, these blocked arteries would have absolutely nothing to do with my pain.
This fundamental paradox is the source of a lot of the overtesting and over treatment that occurs in cardiology. Most of the time, chest pain that prompts a patient to come to the ER or doctor’s office does not fall easily into the non cardiac category or the typical anginal category: these are the atypical anginal patients.
Additional testing is required , progressing from EKGS and cardiac enzymes to stress testing to cardiac catheterization. If there are elevation of the cardiac enzymes or abnormalities of the EKG that indicate a recent or active heart attack then a cardiac catheterization is warranted because it is very highly likely that a tightly blocked coronary artery is the cause and opening that artery will be beneficial.
However, most patients have normal cardiac enzymes and unremarkable EKGS and can end up getting catheterizations (due to either inaccurate stress tests or cardiologist’s recommendation) that they don’t need.
Once a catheterization is done, patients may then get a stenting procedure on a blocked coronary artery that wasn’t causing any problems. Not uncommonly, multiple blocked coronary arteries are found and the patient is rushed off to have a bypass operation. If the blocked arteries weren’t the cause of the patient’s chest pain (i.e. the pain was non cardiac) these procedures are likely doing more harm than good.
When To Go To ER With Chest Pain
I’ve spent thirty years fielding after hours telephone calls from patients who are having chest pain.
It is not easy to make a reliable determination of who is likely having a heart attack or other potentially dangerous cardiac problem and who is not just based on the history.
If a patient called me describing what I described above I would likely advise him to go to the ER for evaluation (although I would be pretty sure it wasn’t a heart attack: sometimes rib fractures are associated with collapsed lungs or hemorrhage into the pleural space and sometimes trauma to the chest can cause heart damage). It’s always better to err on the side of caution when were’ dealing with potentially life-threatening problems.
After office hours, the only way to get an electrocardiogram and cardiac enzymes to be sure that the chest pain is or is not a heart attack is to go to an ER. Generally, if the patient has escalated the level of concern to calling the on call cardiologist, the symptoms are worrisome.
The bottom line for me is that you only get one chance to die (You only die once (YODO)
If you’re having a heart attack at any second your heart can go into ventricular tachycardia or ventricular fibrillation and you will die within minutes.
Thus, I have to have a very low threshold for advising trips to the ER. If I’m wrong, the patient could die.
I didn’t go to the ER because I was 100% certain that my chest pain was non cardiac. I’m also a doctor and therefore a very bad patient. I survived, however, and over several weeks the pain gradually subsided.
As a result of this fall (and several other bike falls I’ve had in the last few years) I’ve re-evaluated my cycling. I’m going to stay on very well-maintained paths and slow way down when the going gets rough.
Hopefully, this will allow me to continue the cycling which I’m convinced is helping to prevent me from visiting the ER with a true heart attack!
2 thoughts on “I'm Having Chest Pain: Is It a Heart Attack?”
So interesting Dr P that despite seriously hurting yourself you were able to offer such a good analysis of the problem. I think that when I was a youngster of your age I would have been very tempted to veer off down that spur and investigate the unknown. Did you crack any ribs?
The injury behaved like a rib fracture but a CT a few weeks later done for other reasons did not reveal any evidence for fracture so I’m calling it a rib contusion