(This post was updated 4/13/2023)
Sometimes AliveCor’s Mobile ECG device yields unclassified interpretations of recordings.
Understandably if you want to know whether your rhythm is normal or atrial fibrillation, the unclassified classification can be very frustrating.
There are various caues of an unclassified tracing with different solutions. In the past, some unclassified recordings were due to a heart rate over 100 BPM or under 50 BPM and could not be fixed. Kardia now (2023) will describe these as tachycardia and bradycardia respectively.
When I first wrote this article in 2016 I noted that “patients with ectopic beats like PVCS may consistently generate unclassified interpretations (see my discussion here).” Kardia is now capable of identifying PVCs and premature atrial contractions if one subscribes to their Advanced Determinations.
Noise or Artifact Related to Poor Technique
Artifacts induced by poor recording techniques are common as a cause and almost always can be fixed.
These can be reduced by minimizing motion, extraneous noise, and maximizing contact with the electrodes. Follow all the steps AliveCor lists here.
For me, the following step is crucial
If your fingers are dry, try moistening them with antibacterial wipes or a bit of lotion
Low Voltage As Cause of Unclassified Kardia Recordings
Another cause of unclassified interpretations is a low voltage recording (which I initially discussed here.).
Low voltage recordings are often due to a vertically oriented heart. Recording using the lead II technique can often solve the problem.
Lead II involves putting one electrode on your left knee and one your right fingers as described in this video:
Reader “J” recently sent me a series of Kardia ECG recordings, some of which were unclassified, some normal and one read as possible atrial fibrillation.
The unclassified and possible AF tracings looked like this:
They were very regular with a rate between 80 and 100 BPM but they totally lacked p waves. It was not clear to me what the rhythm was from these tracings.
Other tracings had lowish voltage but the p waves were clearly visible and Kardia easily classified them as normal
Still others had improved QRS voltage with clear p waves and were also classified appropriately as normal
After some back and forth emails we discovered that the ECG recordings with no p waves were always made using the chest lead recording. AliveCor-describes this as follows:
- For an Anterior Precordial Lead, the device can be placed on the lower left side of the chest, just below the pectoral muscle. The bottom of the smartphone or tablet should be pointing towards the center of the body.
There is an abnormal cardiac rhythm that is regular between 80 and 100 BPM with no p waves and normal QRS called junctional tachycardia but in J’s case the absent p waves are related to the recording site.
Also, note that for this young woman the lead II voltage (Type B tracing) is much higher than the standard, lead I voltage (type A tracing).
Lead II With Pants On
After Dr. Albert told me of the advantages of Lead II I responded that it seemed somewhat awkward to take one’s pants off in order to make an ECG recording.
He immediately reached in his suit pocket and pulled out a pen-shaped device and began spraying a liquid on his left knee.
To my surprise he was able to make a perfect Lead II recording without taking his pants off!
Lessons learned from reader J and Dr. A:
- Consider trying different leads if the standard Lead I (left hand, right hand) is consistently yielding unclassified ECG recordings
- Try Lead II (left knee, right hand) to improve voltage and recording quality
- You can record off your knee even with your pants on if you are prepared to spray liquids on your pants